Several years ago, I wrote a series of blog posts in celebration and observance of Banned Books Week. To date–along with Replacing Required Reading–this series has been by far the most popular thing on The Plucky Reader. But I’ve noticed an interesting trend. As more books are being challenged and banned in conservative states, my posts about banned and challenged books have been gaining more traction. And it makes sense: people want to know about the things that are being brought into question. So as a staunch supporter of the freedom to read, I feel it is not only my duty to celebrate these challenged books, but also to provide some statistics and information about the state of book bans in America.
I will also take a look at another of my favorite banned books, The Hate U Give. I have written briefly about this book in the past, but I figured it was time to show it the love it deserved.
But first, some history and statistics (I’m still a teacher a heart, after all.)
Throughout history, books have been banned for a plethora of reasons, ranging from political dissent and religious beliefs to explicit content and even inaccurate information. Some of the most famous banned books include To Kill a Mockingbird, The Catcher in the Rye, and The Grapes of Wrath. These books often challenge societal norms and encourage readers to think critically about the world around them, which is precisely what makes them so important.
Last September, PenAmerica posted the results of a study surrounding banned books, specifically focusing on the modern-day conversations around banning books. Their findings were unsurprising to say the least, but to see everything written out sent a chilling message about the state of things today.
Books featuring people or color or members of the LGBTQ+ community were the most commonly challenged. In staggering numbers, in fact. And while other factors came into play, it is clear that the othering of people of these two protected people groups is the most prominent reason for a challenge of a book.
It’s also important to note where these books are being banned and challenged. Texas, with its infinite “pick me” energy, leads the pack. But good ole’ where-dreams-go-to-die Florida isn’t too far behind. You can see the full details broken down below in a beautiful map graphic.
So now on to The Hate U Give.
Angie Thomas’s debut novel, The Hate U Give, was published in 2017 and quickly became a bestseller, earning rave reviews from both critics and readers alike. At its core, “The Hate U Give” tells the story of Starr Carter, a young girl who must navigate the turbulent waters of two very different worlds – her predominantly black, lower-income neighborhood and her mostly white, affluent private school. When she witnesses the tragic shooting of her childhood friend Khalil by a police officer, she is thrust into the spotlight, and forced to confront the injustices that have plagued her community for years.
Thomas expertly weaves a story that is both intimate and universal, giving readers a window into the complexities of Starr’s life and the broader implications of her experience. The novel is an emotional rollercoaster, filled with moments of heartache, anger, and, ultimately, hope.
One of the most striking aspects of “The Hate U Give” is the authenticity of its characters. Thomas has a unique ability to bring her characters to life, making them feel like real people with genuine emotions and experiences. Starr’s voice is raw and honest, drawing readers in and allowing them to experience her world through her eyes.
The novel is filled with a diverse cast of characters that represent a wide range of perspectives, allowing readers to see the various ways people are affected by and respond to the issues raised in the story.
The Hate U Give doesn’t shy away from addressing complex and difficult issues such as police brutality, systemic racism, and the impact of media on public perception. Thomas encourages readers to think critically about these topics and engage in meaningful conversations about how to create positive change.
By presenting these issues through the lens of a relatable and engaging story, Thomas makes these topics more approachable and helps readers understand the challenges faced by marginalized communities on a more personal level.
Despite its success, The Hate U Give has faced its fair share of controversy. The novel has been challenged and even banned in some schools and libraries across the United States for various reasons, such as the use of profanity, drug use, and the portrayal of police violence. Critics argue that the book’s content is inappropriate for young readers, while others feel it promotes anti-police sentiments.
In the face of these challenges, it’s imperative we recognize the importance of The Hate U Give and other books that tackle difficult subjects. Thomas’s novel provides a much-needed perspective on the experiences of marginalized communities and the systemic issues they face daily. By giving a voice to the voiceless, The Hate U Give encourages empathy, understanding, and promotes dialogue around topics that are often deemed too uncomfortable or controversial.
It’s crucial to remember that by banning books like The Hate U Give, we are doing a disservice to ourselves and future generations. Literature has the power to change hearts and minds, to encourage empathy, and to foster understanding. Instead of shying away from challenging books, let’s celebrate them and the invaluable perspectives they bring to our lives.
Paul Randall Adams 
Leave a Reply